Writer Reviews of Author Salon - Novel Writing Program
Author Salon writers become authors the old fashioned way. They earn it.
Through the work involved in ACT ZERO, I've become a believer in backstory. The going has been challenging--at first, I worried that I didn't have time to write anecdotes that may or may not come into the book. But then the effort paid in spades when I saw a significant opportunity (through one of those anecdotes) to deepen the inner conflict of the main character and allow for a link to the antagonist that I would never have imagined without this intense groundwork.
The Sympathetic Character Factors in the Hook, forced me to more closely examine my protagonist. She was/is a sympathetic character to me, but the assignment requires that I articulate and then give evidence that reflects sympathetic character traits. Again, that work resulted in a richer grab; this facet of the program has helped me create stronger main and supporting characters.
- Janet Zupan - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
Learning and practicing the four levels of third person narrative POV had the biggest impact on my writing. The zoom lens effect of author POV/distant/close/first-close gives the narrative more depth and energy, allowing the reader to not only see what a character sees, but to get right inside their head and hear their inner thoughts--perhaps the ultimate show-don't-tell technique.
- Lois Gordon - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
I had not expected that strengthening the depth of my characters' lives both past and present would so naturally work to form plot. Module 6-8 (6-Act) then created a visual image of my novel as a whole that helped me ensure I had the necessary elements for a publishable novel. I was also surprised how helpful Module 2 (Antagonist) was in developing strong plot line. By fleshing out an antagonist, and an in-depth backstory, the overall plot was transformed.
- Brittany Hughes - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
The AS course directs focus on specifics in each character's backstory, a technique that helped make the characters become more vivid, taking substantive form in my mind's eye. As a result, as I lay relaxing in a hot bath or driving to get groceries, scenes would pop into my mind which, while dictated by the constraints of story, were fully driven by character.
- Walter Thompson - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
Sincerely, every module was very helpful. I could write a case for each one. Detailing the climax gave me a window in to how to seed foreshadowing throughout the novel. I love the way subtle foreshadowing is a gift for astute readers--I want to give that gift. Too often foreshadowing is heavy-handed or non-existent. If I didn't know exactly where I was headed (climax) then I wouldn't have the intimacy with the overall plotline necessary to plant these little gems.
- Sela Gaglia - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
The Author Salon program has forced me to more carefully consider the vital details of the novel writing process as a whole. The emphasis on backstory and the development of theme, scene creation in the context of the six act plot structure, and of course, the module on the antagonist. The course has also helped me to be more aware of marketability.
- John Loving - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
Author Salon's writing program modules have strengthened my novel. The most surprising was the section concerning the antagonist. I realized the character I'd identified as the antagonist was insufficiently dimensional. He was mostly off-stage, and questions pertaining to his actions and motivation revealed his lack of importance. I could have created content, but strangely enough, he was not a pivotal point. After second and third thoughts, I identified the true villain. Once I worked through the assignment, she became a fascinating creature intimately related to the theme.
Another assignment was to describe the history of a setting. I chose the novel's Texas ranch, which had been merely a literary device. After researching and considering this locale, I found it to have a rich component that added depth to the story. The discovery was thrilling.
- Chance Maree - Author Salon Novel Writing Program Review
The primary attribute required to be successful on the site is a desire to get better at what you do, no matter who you are and where your skills sit on the continuum of experience and ability. The second attribute is an open mind and a thick skin. You’ll receive critique with greater depth than the typical MFA workshop."
- Martina Newhook, author of A BULLET FOR SIMONE
"And I’ve joined what is a promising venture, the on-line book clearinghouse Author Salon. The idea behind Author Salon, which debuted late last year, is to provide agents and editors information on strongly conceptualized and carefully vetted book projects. To have a project up on Author Salon requires it go through three phases of peer review and critique. Then “marquee” projects become available to the agents and editors (and film people) who enroll in the site. In a sense, it reverses the current paradigm, which forces authors to do the searching."
The process so far has proven enormously useful in helping me to conceptualize the novel and talk about it coherently.
- Nathaniel Popkin, author of BOOK OF MASTERS
"I’ve met friendly, creative, determined writers on this site. Their critique comments are well thought through and demonstrate how seriously they take the process and how much they have engaged with my work. Every genre is represented here: young adult, middle grade, fantasy, sci fi, narrative nonfiction, general nonfiction, fiction (women’s upscale, literary, historical), thriller, mystery, detective, romance, paranormal romance. I know I’m missing some. Whatever you write – it’s in here and there are plenty of other people in your genre ready to sign on to work with you."
- Chris Stewart, author of THIS END UP
"Now that I told you what Author Salon is, I can tell you what it is not. It’s not a writing circle or review site for people who are tinkering with the idea of becoming writers. This is for serious work-to-publish authors. It’s for professionals; those who don’t follow the rules are shown the door. It is also not for the faint-of-heart or thin-skinned. Your peers and the site facilitators will be blunt. If you do not heed their advice, you don’t move up the tiers. "
- Brian Braden, author of BLACK SEA GODS
"It is through the power of robust communities of writers that we learn how to put forward the best version of our work so that it has its own chance out in the world. I wanted to share the knowledge of this incredible website with my friends who are similarly looking for their big W. By using the road map that Author Salon provides I feel confident that every one of us who is participating in this process will one day become the Writer they hope to be. "
- Jenny Poore, author of THE LAST GOOD NIGHT
"Author Salon requires any opinion, positive or negative, to be substantiated with an explanation for its basis. Now that it’s necessary to write a coherent critique, rather than deliver it verbally, I tend to analyze the reasons for my conclusions more carefully, and to force myself to articulate my thought process. It’s a workout for my brain that, at times, literally makes it sore.
The compensation comes from knowing that the exercise is strengthening my critical thinking muscles, and that the results will be reflected in my own writing."
- Sharen Ford, author of DAYS IN THE YELLOW LEAF
"Editors and agents know that by the time writers are sitting in front of them to pitch their work, the facilitators have slapped them into shape; they are ready. So this is an online version of a pitch conference – an ongoing one – but with many added features and in-depth analysis of each author’s work.
Through the process of putting the aspects of one’s book into the various categories and elements on the site, one is reminded every so often, that if you don’t want to do the work, this isn’t the place for you. They aren’t “nice” but they are clear. Only serious and dedicated writers are welcome."
- Deepam Susan Wadds, author of THE COST OF WEATHER
"So I was excited when a colleague introduced me to Author Salon, a new initiative aimed at helping authors prepare to pitch and market their manuscripts. It is a win:win community wherein the author is able to hone their work, while agents and publishers can delve in knowing these writers have done their due diligence.
When you sign up for Author Salon there are a lot of questions about your work. Often these questions make you look at your manuscript through new eyes. This is essentially the idea, that you see it not as the writer, but as the agent or publisher."
- Alon Shalev, author of THE WYCCAN MASTER
"They bill Author Salon as a place “where you become an author the old-fashioned way — you earn it”. This, is true. You have to critique 5 other people’s work as well as your own, and constantly be revising and editing. But so far I have encountered hard, driving criticism that has actually transformed how I see my book and myself writing it, and everyone has been fully supportive as I work through that slow turnaround. Some folks have left, citing the requirements as too stringent and the people running the place as being inflexible and controlling. I disagree – these are professionals who know what they are doing ..."
- Melissa Elmes, author of MERRIN BORN
"This is why I included the word “serious” in my post title: unlike the label “Author Salon” suggests, this website is NO day at the spa. I could immediately tell that the experts who put the concept together wanted to weed out writers who were not prepared to go the distance with their work. This produces a great side-effect; those that remain are pretty high quality writers, and therefore are able to provide high quality feedback in the peer review process.
And then there are the experts. I never would have expected or asked for this, but some of the administrative staff of the website (experienced editors, published authors, agents, and the like) occasionally take the time to engage Author Salon members in one-on-one discussions about their work-in-progress. Like, in depth discussions. The type of advice that I would have paid real money for if someone had offered me the chance to spend it! I cannot say enough about how great that has been for the progress of THE PROVING."
- Kevin Jackson, author of THE PROVING
"From the moment you start setting up your profile, you can tell this is tailored for serious authors. Every section you have to fill out will make you dig deep into your novel. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if the process helps you uncover holes in the plot or weaknesses in the characters. The site provides specific instructions and examples for different genres. You will be expected to describe the hook, conflict, stakes, protagonist, antagonist, climax, etc. You will also be required to provide samples of your dialogue, opening, characters, and setting. And you’d better do a good job, because your profile will determine your project status. If your hook, doesn’t hook and your narrative doesn’t pop. Forget it!"
- Ingrid Seymour, author of ONE WISH AWAY